There's nothing wrong with your points. It's just my opinion on the way it looks based on what she has done and the state of her mind set this time. I'm not comparing her to the others girls. I don't do that. I base my thinking on what each girl does herself and her personality not what she does compared to the other girls. For me if you don't consider the girls personality (what we can surmise of it) and their mind set (same thing as before) then any comparison is flawed.